Skip to content

Your Relative Died Before the Case Settled. Who Gets Paid, and in What Order

The Admission Packet
Subject
Pursuing complaints and legal claims over abuse and neglect in nursing homes and assisted living facilities in the United States
Editor
The The Admission Packet team
Subject
Pursuing complaints and legal claims over abuse and neglect in nursing homes and assisted living facilities in the United States
Your Relative Died Before the Case Settled. Who Gets Paid, and in What Order
Contingency rates in facility cases often rise at set milestones, such as filing suit or setting a trial date. The agreement should state each rate and the exact event that triggers it.
  1. Gross versus net calculation

    Taking the fee before costs are deducted yields a different result than taking it after, on the identical settlement. Ask the firm to run the math on a sample figure and put it in the file.

  2. Who fronts expert fees

    Nursing standard-of-care experts, causation physicians and life care planners are the largest single cost item in most neglect cases. Firms typically advance these and recover them from the settlement.

  3. Costs if the case loses

    Some agreements forgive advanced costs when a case is lost or withdrawn and some do not. This is a specific clause to locate rather than assume.

A careful reader checks five things in a nursing home case: the fee percentage, the cost line, whether the claim splits in two, the state cap, and the liens.

The fee agreement in a nursing home abuse or neglect case is usually two pages and looks like a formality next to the medical records, but it decides more about the family's outcome than almost anything else signed later. So does the question of who owns the claim once the resident has died, which in most states is not the person who noticed the bruises or made the calls. A careful reader works through both before signing, and the order below is the order the money actually moves in.

1. Find out whether the percentage comes off the gross or the net

Contingency percentages in facility cases commonly step up as the matter progresses, one rate if it resolves before suit is filed, a higher one after the case is filed or after a trial date is set. The percentage itself is the part everyone compares. The more consequential clause is the one setting whether the fee is calculated on the gross recovery or on the recovery after case costs are subtracted, because on the same settlement those two methods produce visibly different checks. Ask for the arithmetic worked on a hypothetical number, in writing, before signing anything.

2. Treat case costs as a separate account, because that is what they are

Costs are not the fee and are not covered by it. In a pressure ulcer or fall case the list runs to records retrieval from several facilities and hospitals, a nursing standard-of-care expert, often a physician expert on causation, a life care planner where the resident survived, court reporters, filing fees, and mediation. Firms advance these and recoup them from the recovery. The clause worth reading closely is what happens to advanced costs if the case is lost or dropped, and whether the firm charges interest on money it has fronted. Many do not. Some do.

3. Understand that the resident's death usually creates two claims, not one

Most states split what happened into a survival claim, which belongs to the estate and covers what the resident personally endured before dying, and a wrongful death claim, which belongs to a defined class of statutory beneficiaries and covers their loss. The two are pleaded together and settled together, then allocated apart. Allocation matters because the survival portion flows into the probate estate, where creditors can reach it, while the wrongful death portion generally goes to the beneficiaries and is far harder for a creditor to touch. That single allocation decision can move tens of thousands of dollars.

4. Check how the state's damage cap applies to each of those claims

Many states cap noneconomic damages in cases sounding in medical malpractice, and whether a nursing home case is characterized as ordinary negligence or as malpractice determines whether the cap bites at all. Where a cap applies, read the statute for what it applies to: a per-claimant cap, a per-defendant cap, and a per-occurrence cap all produce different ceilings when a corporate parent, an operating entity and a management company are all named. Economic losses, funeral expenses and past medical bills are usually outside the cap. Punitive damages have their own separate rules.

5. Count the liens before you count the recovery

Whatever comes back is reduced by whoever paid for the care in the first place. Medicare asserts a conditional payment claim through its recovery contractor, Medicaid programs assert a lien against the portion attributable to medical expenses, and Medicaid estate recovery may separately pursue the deceased resident's probate estate for long-term care benefits paid after age fifty-five. The Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services oversees the federal side of both programs. Private health plans and hospital lienholders add to the stack. Liens are frequently negotiable, sometimes substantially, and reduction is ordinary practice rather than an exception.

6. Confirm who has authority to sign the release

A defendant will not pay without a release signed by someone with legal power to give one, which means a personal representative appointed by the probate court for the survival claim and, depending on the state, either that representative or the statutory beneficiaries for the wrongful death claim. Opening a small estate takes weeks and costs a filing fee. Doing it early, rather than after a settlement is agreed, keeps the money from sitting in trust while a court schedules a hearing. Ask at the first meeting who will be appointed and when.

A family that has read the fee clause, priced the costs, seen the allocation proposal and asked for the lien numbers in writing knows what the case is worth to them, not just what it is worth on paper. That is a short list of questions, and every one of them has an answer available before the first record is ordered.